Dunedin Blue Jays Fall Short as Palm Beach Cardinals Turn Early Lead Into a 7-5 Gut Punch

A hot start, a cold finish

The Dunedin Blue Jays brought the early fireworks. The Palm Beach Cardinals stuck around to collect the receipt.

A 3-0 lead became a 5-3 lead, which became a 7-5 loss. If you’re looking for the short version of a frustrating night in Dunedin, there it is: plenty to cheer about early, plenty to mutter about afterward.

For Pinellas fans watching around Dunedin, Clearwater, St Pete or the beaches, this was the kind of game that starts with confident baseball talk and ends with somebody staring into a cup. The Jays had the advantage. They just couldn’t make it last.

The trouble wasn’t a lack of an opening act. It was that Dunedin’s offense practically packed up after the third inning while Palm Beach still had business to conduct.

The Jays supplied the spark

Dunedin got moving in the second. Dean West singled home Brayden Martin, and Rhylan Thomas followed with the swing that made the home crowd’s night look promising: a double to center that scored West and Jake Cook.

Blue Jays 3, Cardinals 0. A perfectly pleasant arrangement, unless you happened to be Palm Beach.

Sebastian Dos Santos handled that objection in the third, launching a three-run homer to right that brought home J.P. Cabrera and Travis Honeyman. Just like that, the cushion was gone and the game was tied 3-3.

To Dunedin’s credit, the answer came immediately. Martin singled in Juan Sanchez, then Ryan Cooney scored on Cook’s groundout. The Jays were back ahead 5-3, having taken a punch and returned one.

That response deserved a better sequel. Instead, Palm Beach’s pitching kept Dunedin off the scoreboard for the rest of the game. An offense that had been finding ways to bring runners home stopped cashing in altogether.

Thomas finished 1-for-4 with 2 RBI, his second-inning double remaining the standout Dunedin swing. Miguel Pantoja worked 3.1 innings on the mound, allowing 5 hits and 3 earned runs while striking out 3.

The sixth changed the conversation

Palm Beach didn’t need another homer to take control. The Cardinals dismantled the lead with a groundout and a pair of doubles in the sixth.

Owen Henne’s groundout scored Dos Santos to cut it to 5-4. Miguel Hernández then doubled to right, bringing Matthew Miura home and tying the game. Trevor Haskins followed with a double to center that put Palm Beach ahead 6-5.

No mystery, no complicated diagnosis. Three runs, a vanished lead and a Dunedin lineup that couldn’t produce an answer.

Henne added a solo homer to left in the eighth, stretching the Cardinals’ advantage to 7-5. That gave Palm Beach breathing room; Dunedin never found a way to take it back.

Dos Santos finished 2-for-4 with 2 runs scored and 3 RBI. His homer erased the first lead, and his run in the sixth helped unravel the next one. Not exactly the guest you invite back for the tailgate.

For the local postgame debate, the point is straightforward: scoring early counts, but it doesn’t reserve the result. Dunedin answered Palm Beach’s first rally. It had nothing for the second.

The full box score has the details. For the next chance to trade the postgame grumbling for something worth cheering, check the Dunedin schedule.

Our Tampa Bay sports coverage is presented by the Bud Light Sports Zone.